I mean, he paints you as a kind of ice princess. That's even what he calls you. You were his Ice Princess, and I'm his Violet Guru. That's a reference to the way I only see one spectrum of light, the best things about people, and the way I give advice. I see everybody in a purple light, he says, it makes them all sound more magical than they are, and I'm maybe a kind of spiritual teacher. You were an Ice Princess because he could do whatever he wanted to you, and you wouldn't care. You'd just blink and brush it off, he said. You were tough. Not bogged down with emotion like me. Nope. You never cried about anything. You'd let him get away with anything, because you were impossible to crack.
He says he even told you about how often he'd cheat on you. He says he told you about how much he missed me, and you brushed it off. He told me that he'd leave you, then come back to you, over and over again in a cycle. This just reaffirmed your title, to me. I was there when he texted you that he was done with you. He and I were on a road trip in Oregon; we'd just left the airport and I gave him the last ultimatum I've ever given him: Emily or me. He texted you that it was over, and you said "Haha, okay." I thought that meant that you'd already moved on, or that you didn't really care about him. It was so casual. And I made him talk about you for hours on that trip. I wanted to know why he'd picked me over you, and what would stop him from going back to you again? Mostly, I didn't want to become you. I didn't want to be the girl he shook his fists at while he was cycling.
Turns out, nothing. He tried to get you back a few months later, he drunkenly confessed to me in a hotel room. And you responded so succinctly, with so much pent-up anger, that I realized I was wrong. You hadn't moved on. You had just come to expect the same behavior from him that I had. You responded that he had ended the most significant relationship you'd ever had with a text message. You told him to fuck off, and to stay with me. I started screaming when I read that, and crying. I threw his phone at him and screamed "What did you do to her?" It was the first time I realized that Gideon just hurts people, no exception. I stopped hating you that night - from then on, all I could do was empathize. I thought then that you were doing me a favor. You were letting me keep him. Really, you were just doing what was ultimately best for you. I want you to know that you made the right choice, and I know how hard it was.
We've never met. We're never going to meet and you're never going to read this. I'm sure after all we've been through, after he bounced from me, to you, back to me, and probably with ten other women in between, you want nothing to do with this anymore. I just want to tell you that I'm sorry. I think I understand now why you always reacted the way you did. I'm sorry I let his description of you color my mental image of this girl he left me for. You weren't an ice princess or the cool girl. You were another smart, beautiful girl that he enchanted and then hurt. You weren't really different from me, and I'm so sorry I ever hated you.
If I did ever meet you, my questions would all be selfish: Did you move on? How did you move on? When did you stop worrying that you'd never meet someone as charming, as creative, as fun, as sexy, as all-compassing as him? Was does it feel like to breath again?
If I did ever meet you, my questions would all be selfish: Did you move on? How did you move on? When did you stop worrying that you'd never meet someone as charming, as creative, as fun, as sexy, as all-compassing as him? Was does it feel like to breath again?